Yale Climate Day 2024 - Judge and Peer Review Form
This form is to be used by expert judges as well as by peer reviewers (= other poster presenters).

Judges/peer-reviewers: for each poster presentation, please complete one of these forms.

For peer reviewers: please score the 2 posters IMMEDIATELY TO THE RIGHT OF YOUR POSTER.

Thank you for your engagement with Yale Climate Day!
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Your full name *
Your Yale NetID *
Are you an expert judge OR a peer-reviewer? *
Name of lead presenter whose poster you are scoring *
Overall appearance (10 pts) *
The poster looks professional and is aesthetically pleasing. Space is used effectively, and neither text nor graphics dominate. Infographics/pictures serve a purpose (not just filling space), and are appropriately titled and captioned.
(1=Lowest score)
(10=Highest score)
Organizational flow (5 pts) *
There is an organization flow with appropriate headings and clearly defined sections. All of the information is provided in a logical order.
(1=Lowest score)
(5=Highest score)
Main points (5 pts) *
The fundamental points of the study are clearly identified, with little redundancy of information.
(1=Lowest score)
(5=Highest score)
Scientific content (5 pts) *
Is the scientific content novel? Well-supported? Does it appear to represent a significant advance on our understanding of the climate system or its impacts and/or regulation?
(1=Lowest score)
(5=Highest score)
Summary (5 pts) *
Does the poster address the implications of the study?
(1=Lowest score)
(5=Highest score)
Presentation & question handling (5 pts) *
(1=Lowest score)
(5=Highest score)
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy
Google Forms