IHII/McLaughlin Colloquium on Infection and Immunity SCORING SHEET

JavaScript isn't enabled in your browser, so this file can't be opened. Enable and reload.

Instructions: Please consider the following two general categories of criteria and score the independently, then sum.

Email *

Judge Name (confidential) *

Field of Judge *

Presenters Name *

Presenter is a: *

Graduate Student, PhD year 1 or 2 or Master's

Graduate Student, PhD, after qualifying exam

Post-doctoral fellow

Clinical Fellow

Other

Field of Presenter *

Scientific Merit and Impact

- Was the introduction informative and relevant?
- Is there a critical analysis of the current knowledge? Was the
presenter able to place the data in the larger context of scientific
or medical knowledge?
- Was the hypothesis logical and well-stated?
- Were the techniques appropriate to resolve the problem?
- Is the data analysis appropriate?
- Does this work add new knowledge?
- Were the conclusions presented supported by the data?
- Did the presenter discuss future studies and implications?

Scientific Merit and Impact *

6 Outstanding

5 Better than Average

4 Average

3 Below Average

2 Fair

1 Poor

Organization and Presentation

- Was the poster organized, concise, and to the point?
- Was the presentation effective and clear?
- Were the presenter’s answers to questions pertinent?
- Did the presenter demonstrate mastery of the state of the art in
his or her field?

Organization and Presentation *

SUM OF ABOVE SCORES *

Submit

Clear form

Never submit passwords through Google Forms.

This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Forms