Feedback must be substantive, constructive, and at least 25 words. It must focus on at least one thing you liked about the performance before talking about areas of potential improvement. The more specific, the better. When discussing what another player might improve upon, focus on things that are within the player’s ability to control.

Hosts will be curating feedback before publication. Hosts reserve the right to leave insubstantial and/or uncharitable feedback unpublished, and users who submit inappropriate or unnecessarily harsh critiques may receive penalties, up to and including ejection from the game. Remember, this is a friendly game, and this is for fun.

For examples of good critiques, check out the judges’ notes from Time to Shine (https://tinyurl.com/TimeToShineJudges) and EM Idol (https://tinyurl.com/EMI7Judges)