Welcome to the survey on a proposal for a new DH Conference review form

JavaScript isn't enabled in your browser, so this file can't be opened. Enable and reload.

The goal of this survey is to collect feedback from the DH community on the proposal for a new review form for ConfTool to be used in future iterations of ADHO's international Digital Humanities Conference.

Whether you've reviewed for the DH conference, or have received reviews for submissions at the DH conference, or have experience with similar processes at other conferences, please feel welcome to participate in the survey. (And if you feel that it might be useful to describe your perspective on the issue, or your level of experience with reviewing, or provide any other contextual information, you may do so using the last field in the survey called "any other comments".)

The proposal can be consulted on Google Docs in read-only mode: both some notes on the rationale for a revised review form, and the proposed new review form itself.

Please use the form below to provide your feedback on the proposal. There, you can provide comments relating to each section of the review form. You are welcome to provide feedback on as few or as many sections as you would like. (Also, you can edit your response and/or provide multiple rounds of feedback, if necessary.)

We are monitoring the incoming feedback and will add comments summarizing recurrent or particularly relevant feedback to the Google Doc, so that others can build on such feedback.

The form will remain open until July 31st, 2023.

Please also note that your input is collected only for the purposes of gathering feedback and improving the review form. It will not be made publicly available other than in summarized and anonymized form, through the comments in the Google Doc. Indicating your real name and/or email address is optional.

If you have any questions or suggestions on the process, please feel welcome to contact Christof Schöch at schoech@uni-trier.de.

Name (or initials / nickname, if you prefer) *

Email (optional)

Feedback concerning the text presenting the review form

Your comments on the section "Objectives and problem description"

Your comments on the section "Design goals"

Your comments on the section "Design principles"

Your comments on the section "Challenges and other comments"

Feedback concerning the review form itself

Note that your are welcome to comment on any aspect of each question, whether the question itself, the options provided to answer it, or any other aspect related to that question.

Comments on question 1: "Does the submission include a substantial description of the current state of knowledge and best practices in the area(s) relevant to the work, and is that description backed up by useful references? (20%)"

Comments on question 2: "Does the work described in the submission go beyond the current state of knowledge and best practices in the areas(s) relevant to the work? (20%)"

Comments on question 3: "Does the submission describe its approach or method with sufficient detail for readers to understand what was done and why it was done, within the limitations of the abstract format? (20%)"

Comments on question 4: "Does the submission have a clear structure and comprehensible language that support readers in understanding the submission? (10%)"

Comments on question 5: "Does the submission adhere to the formal expectations regarding abstract length (neither too long nor too short) and bibliographic references (consistent referencing and citation style)? (10%)"

Comments on question 6: "Does the submission support diversity, in the sense that it describes work that increases the diversity of topics, approaches and perspectives at the DH conference, and/or does it give adequate recognition to relevant scholarly work by members of disadvantaged or under-represented groups? (10%)"

Comments on reviewer confidence 1: "How familiar are you with the topic and methods of the submission?"

Comments on reviewer confidence 2: "How familiar are you with the annual Digital Humanities Conference offered by ADHO?"

Any other comments: If there is anything else you would like to communicate, please feel free to use this section.

Submit

Clear form

Never submit passwords through Google Forms.

This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

Forms