2020 Spring HDISystems Reviews
Due Monday midnight before class

Topics of consideration in your reviews:
* What is the paper about?
* What is significant (above prior work) and why?  Do you agree?
* Technical strengths beyond prior work: I like ….
* Limitations: I wish ….
* Extensions: What if ….?

Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Name *
UNI *
Review for paper 1 *
IN ADDITION to the standard review, consider and respond to the following prompts. This paper describes the notion of an "explanation".   What is it explaining and what constitutes a good vs bad explanation?   What are the considerations of the problem that makes it challenging?
Review for paper 2 *
In addition to the standard review, consider and respond to the following prompts.  DIFF solves a similar, but not exactly the same problem as in Scorpion (in the sense that there are problems that Scorpion can solve that DIFF cannot).  Comment or speculate on what those are.    Also, in what ways (metrics) does DIFF go beyond Scorpion's capabilities?
This week's papers also describe a formulation of explanation for data analysis results.  Argue why it is compelling and useful.  Also contras it from the formulation of explanations from last week's papers.   *
Share ideas/questions you would like us to discuss in class (these will be anonymous to the class)
That's it!  This was the last review for this class.  Thank you for thoughtfully reading and interpreting the papers.  If you would like, please share your feedback about the review process and the selection of papers/topics that we read this semester that could improve the class in future offerings.
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This content is neither created nor endorsed by Google. Report Abuse - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy
Google Forms