Candidates are eligible through four classifications:
 
1) State Champions: Individual and team State Champions from any sport. Candidates shall become eligible for induction five (5) years after graduation.

2) All State: Individuals/teams who have been selected to any recognized All State Team. Candidates shall become eligible for induction five (5) years after graduation.

3) Post High School Achievement: All men and women who earned varsity athletic letters during high school and then after high school brought honor to Bishop Heelan Catholic High School Athletic programs by an outstanding post high school athletic career or in careers related to athletics.

4) Outstanding Contributors: All men and women who have made exceptional contributions to the athletic programs at Bishop Heelan Catholic High School.

Nominations for the 2023 Bishop Heelan Hall of Pride are due on March 15, 2024.