Presentation Judging Score Submission Form for Neuroethics 2024
Complete this form for each virtual or in-person presentation you judge as part of Neuroethics 2024.
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Details
Format *
Presentation Number *
Presenting Author(s) *
Scores
Each presentation is scored on three criteria: topic, clarity, and engagement. Provide a score from 1-5 for each of these criteria. See the qualitative terms to understand generally how to score. Most scores should be in the 2-4 range — representing 'good', 'great' and 'excellent' work — with 5s reserved for the very best 'perfect' work. 
  1. Poor
  2. Good
  3. Great
  4. Excellent
  5. Exceptional
Topic *
Novelty of topic and overall relevance to neuroethics. Clearly articulates a neuroethics problem giving rise to a research question that drives the work. Identifies the importance to neuroethics of any conclusions drawn from the work.
Poor
Exceptional
Clarity *
Clarity of argumentation and presentation are all clear and tightly connected. Employs and clearly identifies research and/or theoretical methods appropriate for the problem and questions raised. Conclusions emerge clearly from these methods.
Poor
Exceptional
Engagement *
Engagement with relevant research and public audiences. Includes relevant background information and engages with extant literature and ethical implications.
Poor
Exceptional
Recognition
If you gave very high scores and think the author should be considered for an award, please select 'yes' below and provide some brief clarifying comments about what stood out about their research and/or presentation.
Award *
Comments
Reviewer
Reviewer Name
 *
Conflict of Interest *
For our purposes, and given our tight-knit community, it's up to you to determine if you do not feel you can be impartial reviewing a presentation for the author(s) in question. Generally, if you're from the same institution or country and know them more than just casually, it's good to declare a conflict for these purposes. And of course, if you are a co-author on this research, you must identify this conflict.
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This form was created inside of neuroethicssociety.org. Report Abuse
Google Forms