Evaluation Film/Digital/TV/Books - Adult/Tween/Teen 2024
Please note, you will receive a response receipt after you submit this. And, you may edit it after submitting if you need to.  Please be sure to answer all questions that are required.
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Email *
Title of product being reviewed *
Please use exact title as we have given to you.
Your Name (first and last) *
Screening Date *
What type of product is this? *
Required
Short description of the product (3-4 sentences) *
Recommended Age Appropriateness (YOUNGEST) *
Based on your expertise, what is the youngest age you recommend this for? Use only numbers, from 0 to 18.
Recommended Age Appropriateness (OLDEST) *
Based on your own experience, recommend the OLDEST most suitable age range. Please follow same instructions for previous question. Use only numbers 1 through 18.
1. Rate overall APPEAL. How much do you like or not like this program? *
5  = Great; 4  = Good; 3  = Good, but...; 2  = OK; 1  = Not Good
Not Good
Great
1a. Tell us why you (as an adult) find it appealing or unappealing. Be specific, give examples. *
1b. Why do you think a child would enjoy this or why not? Be specific. *
2. Rate the overall CONTENT *
5  = Great; 4  = Good; 3  = Good, but...; 2  = OK; 1  = Not Good
Not Good
Great
2a. Comment on the writing, the structure of the show, its continuity and style. *
Does this flow well? Does it make sense? Talk about the structure and style a bit. Describe them. Describe how the screenplay and characters develop. Does it draw you in? Are you empathetic with the characters?
2b. Comment about the accuracy of the material and its suitability for the intended age group. *
Does it use vocabulary and concepts suitable for its intended audience in terms of age and locale? Or not? Give examples.
3. Does it have any negative attributes such as inappropriate sexual behavior, bloody/graphic violence, replicable unsafe behavior, profanity, sexism, racism, or other. *
Refer to the KIDS FIRST! Juror training manual for further descriptions on these. Please give specific examples rather than generic references. i.e. Instead of saying, "It has graphic violence." Say, "there are multiple scenes with bloody, graphic swordplay."
Required
3a. If you marked "yes" above, please describe the aspects you want to warn parents / children of. Please be specific.
Please give specific examples rather than generic references. i.e. Instead of saying, "It has graphic violence." Say, "there are multiple scenes with bloody, graphic sword fights."
4. Rate the overall PRODUCTION QUALITY *
5  = Great; 4  = Good; 3  = Good, but...; 2  = OK; 1  = Not Good
Not good
Great
4a. Tell us about the visual quality, the acting, direction, costumes, sets or locations, music, and similar *
Describe the visual appeal. Are the images clear and easy to identify? If it is a DVD or book, is the cover design appropriate and appealing to its audience? Is it animation or live action? Describe the visuals in relation to its genre.
5. Does it have any special assets such as menu access, chapters, special features or other related items. *
Required
5a. If you answered yes above, please describe them here.
Not everything will have this. Let us know if it does or doesn't. If there is a menu, does it allow you to go to a specific page or chapter? Does it remember where you left off? Does it allow you to listen in different languages (like what?)? Does it have bonus features such as interviews with the director, key talent, animator, or similar? Be specific. .
6. Rate the overall benefits  in terms of entertainment, educational or social benefits *
5  = Great; 4  = Good; 3  = Good, but...; 2  = OK; 1  = Not Good
Not Good
Great
6a. Please describe the benefits. For example, does it invite the viewer to question, probe and problem-solve? Does it teach about cultures or environments we are unfamiliar with? Does it encourage the viewer to look further into a situation, its history, culture or similar? Is the material appropriate for the intended age group? Describe using specific examples.
Does it support inquiry and investigation? Does it encourage the development of critical thinking and problem solving skills? Describe.
7. What is the message of this program? *
8. Final Rating. *
Give your final rating and explain using the criteria below
Required
9. Please use the answers above to summarize a review in approximately 200 words. Be specific. Refer to the worksheet above for key points and bring them into your final review. Be enthusiastic and direct. *
Use the answers you have posted above on this worksheet to guide you in writing your final review. It's okay to duplicate here what you have said previously.
A copy of your responses will be emailed to the address you provided.
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
reCAPTCHA
PrivacyTerms
This form was created inside of Coalition for Quality Children's Media. Report Abuse
Google Forms