Flesh & Blood Misprinted, Damaged & Altered Card Legality Poll: Public Edition

JavaScript isn't enabled in your browser, so this file can't be opened. Enable and reload.

The following is a short poll meant for the judge leads and JCRs, as well as judging community at large, to test their knowledge and come to a general consensus as to what types of cards are acceptable for sanctioned competitive rules enforcement level events. You will be shown a series of images of misprinted and altered card and asked to evaluate whether or not, as head judge, you would allow a player to play the card as is, allow a player to play the card with the correct card information readily available, or disallow the card from being played. Assume that you are head judging a Tier 2 Competitive REL event. Use your best judgment as to whether or not the card is likely to be noticable through a sleeve.

Section 1: Misprinted Cards

The tournament rules and policy states:

Misprinted cards
A misprinted card is card that through a design or printing error, does not accurately represent its intended form. A Player may use an otherwise-legal misprinted card provided it is clear what card it represents and the Player is not using it to create an advantage, such as by having misleading text or pictures. If it’s clear what the misprinted card is, but certain printed information on the card is missing or objectively incorrect (such as colour, power, defence etc.), the Player is required to have the correct information available that their opponent can refer to and point it out when the misprinted card becomes visible to the opponent.

ASSUME ALL QUESTIONS ARE REFERRING TO CARDS PLAYED IN MAIN DECK, EVEN IF THE EXAMPLE IS NOT.

Miscut A (Pitch Stripe Missing, Correct Color on Bottom)