Brighton Collaboration Safety Template Peer Review Form - PHV/Crozet Manuscript
Please complete the review and submit the review form by Thursday, June 16th, 2022.
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Please enter your full name:
Please enter your email address:
Do you agree with the rationale of this manuscript?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
Do you agree with the rationale of this template?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
Does the abstract clearly summarize the intended use of the safety template?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
Does the introduction clearly describe the intended use of the safety template?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
Does the background section and its sub-sections clearly provide reasoning for the intended use of the safety template?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
Please share any edits or comments about the following portions of the manuscript: Disclaimer, Declaration of Competing Interest, Acknowledgements.
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 1. Authorship?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 2. Basic Vector Information?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 3. Characteristics of the wild type virus from which the vector is derived?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 4. Characteristics of the vector from which vaccine(s) may be derived?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 5.  Toxicology and Potency (Pharmacology) of the Vector?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 6.  Adverse Event (AE) Assessment of the Vector?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 7.  Overall Risk Assessment of the Vector?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 8. Target Pathogen and Population for the vaccine?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 9. Characteristics of the Vaccine?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 10. Toxicology and Potency (Pharmacology) of the Vaccine?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 11. Adverse Event (AE) Assessment of the Vaccine?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 12. Overall Risk Assessment of the Vaccine?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
In Table 1, do you agree with all parts of Section 13. Any other information concerning either the viral vector or the vaccine?
Clear selection
If "No" or "Do not know", explain why
Comments
Any other comments you would like to share?
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This form was created inside of The Task Force for Global Health, Inc.. Report Abuse