ORIE 4741 Project Midterm Report Peer Review
Grade the project proposal assigned to you on the following five metrics.
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Email *
What is your NetID? *
What kind of project are you working on? *
What proposal are you are reviewing? (Please double check to make sure it's correct!) *
Copy the comments you made on the project team's Github repo and paste them here. *
Is the report well-written and complete? *
Omits much necessary information, riddled with typos.
Beautifully written, complies with all guidelines.
Has the team collected reasonable, relevant, and sufficient data for their project? *
No, it's not clear where they'll get data.
Yes, it has all been collected and preprocessed in a reasonable way.
Does the team describe how they plan to avoid over (and under-)fitting, and how they will test the effectiveness of their models? *
No, they seem not to be worrying about generalization.
Yes, I am convinved their methodology will yield results that generalize
How convincing and interesting are the team's feature selection and transformations? *
Massively boring
Extremely cool
Has the team conducted preliminary analyses of the data (eg, regressions)? How convincing and interesting are the team's preliminary analyses? *
No analyses
Convincing and extremely cool
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
reCAPTCHA
This form was created inside of Cornell. Report Abuse