SELn Article Review Form

JavaScript isn't enabled in your browser, so this file can't be opened. Enable and reload.

Complete this form for each article being reviewed.
To see the Guidelines for Article Reviewers please visit: https://www.selaonline.org/sela/publications/SEln/articlereviewers.html

Email *

Reviewer Name: (Last Name, First Name) *

Title of Article: *

Context: *

YES

Is this article topic of interest to the library community in the southeast?

Is the article well-researched?

Is the article factually correct?

Organization: *

YES

Is the topic a manageable one?

Is the thesis clearly stated at the outset?

Is the thesis logically developed as the article progresses?

Are the conclusions valid?

Style: *

YES

Is the article succinct?

Is the article clearly written?

Is the article interestingly written?

Editing: How much rewriting will the article need? *

None

Minor

Moderate

Extensive

Recommendation: *

publishable in its current condition

publishable with only minor editorial revisions

requires rewriting to make it publishable

requires major rewriting, and it should be reviewed again after a revised draft is received

does not warrant further consideration by SELn

Comments for the Editor: *

Comments for the Author: (Provide specific examples) *

Send me a copy of my responses.

Submit

Clear form

Never submit passwords through Google Forms.

reCAPTCHA

This form was created inside of University of Mississippi. Report Abuse