ORIE 4741 Project Final Report Peer Review -  Algorithm Design Projects
Grade the project proposal assigned to you on the following metrics.
Sign in to Google to save your progress. Learn more
Email *
What is your NetID? *
What proposal are you are reviewing? (Please double check to make sure it's correct!) *
Copy the comments you made on the project team's Github repo and paste them here. *
Is the report well-written and complete? *
Omits necessary information, riddled with typos, figures hard to interpret
Beautifully written, complies with all guidelines, makes sense
Does the team clearly explain how their project relates to existing work in the published literature? *
No, I couldn't understand how their project fit in
Yes, makes sense (and I learned something!)
Does the team clearly explain their methodology? *
No, I couldn't understand what they were doing
Yes, makes sense (and I learned something!)
Were the theoretical and experimental results interesting and relevant for assessing the potential of the proposed methods? *
No, the results didn't really support the claims
Yes, I found the results convinced me that the methods work well
How effectively does the project use visualization to explain their ideas and results? *
No visualization; or visualizations don't help reader understand
Yes, visualizations are well chosen and interesting
Submit
Clear form
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
reCAPTCHA
This form was created inside of Cornell. Report Abuse